The short answer
Most New Yorkers who move to Philadelphia do it for money: their dollar goes further here, on housing and on everyday costs, and many keep a New York job and commute in once or twice a week. The tradeoffs are Philadelphia’s city wage tax (3.735% for residents), thinner public transit, and a smaller job market. Philadelphia keeps a city feel with more breathing room. These are my notes from helping dozens of people make this move.
I have helped dozens of people relocate from New York to Philadelphia. Some rent, some buy, some invest. I have seen wins, and I have seen things people regret. I have never lived in New York, so I cannot give you a firsthand view of living there. What I can give you is what I have learned from the people I have helped move, plus my own visits. I made the video in October 2025, and I have edited it here for reading.

Jump to a topic in the video
- 1:10 Cost: why people leave New York
- 3:19 The Philadelphia wage tax
- 3:58 Pace and lifestyle
- 6:30 Food and restaurants
- 8:12 Public transportation
- 9:21 Walkability
- 10:56 Jobs and the economy
- 14:16 When to move, and when to stay
Is Philadelphia cheaper than New York City?
The number one thing people tell me when they move from New York to Philadelphia is that the main driver is simply financial. They look at how far their dollar will stretch, and they know it generally stretches a lot farther in Philly.
On housing, I came across a study that compared Manhattan with Philadelphia and found Manhattan housing was generally over 300% more expensive. For New York City overall, the estimate was about 52% higher than Philadelphia. That is pretty astronomical. Some people tell me their money cannot buy them anything in the areas of New York they want to live in, or that they would have to compromise on conveniences. In Philadelphia they can get a more comfortable home and still feel like they are in a large metro area with many of the same conveniences.
It is not only housing. Everyday living costs are higher in New York too. For groceries and restaurants, I would say 20% to 30% higher than comparable things in Philadelphia. People want a similar living situation, but with more space, more bedrooms and more convenient locations in areas that feel kind of like New York.
Checked November 20, 2026
The comparisons above are from the video, recorded in October 2025, and I did not name the study I was referring to, so treat the percentages as rough. For current Philadelphia prices, the median sold price across the county in October 2026 was $290,000 (Bright MLS), and it varies a lot by neighborhood. See our market numbers. Source: Bright MLS via Bright Stats Market Snapshot Report, All Home Types, October 2026 (retrieved November 20, 2026).
Does Philadelphia have a city wage tax?
Yes, and it is one surprise a lot of people do not take into account. Philadelphia has a pretty high city wage tax, and it applies to residents and also to non-residents who work in the city or run their business here. It is a compromise: you get a cheaper living situation and can afford more in your daily spending, but there is a wage tax on your income. Factor it in.
Checked November 20, 2026
Philadelphia’s wage tax is 3.735% for residents and 3.425% for non-residents who work in the city, in effect since July 1, 2026. The rates step down a little each year, which is why the figures in the video are slightly different. Source: City of Philadelphia Department of Revenue. More in our taxes guide.
How is the lifestyle different?
A lot of the people I see coming from New York are looking for a slower pace. New York is a very driven, always-on environment, at least in places like Manhattan where people go out. Some people love it and thrive on it. Others want something a little slower, and I think Philly is a good in-between. You are not moving to the suburbs. You are still in a city, but with a little more breathing room. Center City has hustle and bustle, but it is not overly crowded, and there are a lot of quiet residential neighborhoods with good community vibes.
Neighborhoods like Fishtown have their own nightlife and commercial strips, and they feel like their own community, separate from Center City. I think there is no comparison to New York for sheer energy. If that is what you want, you might want to stick with it. But if you want a city that is quieter and slower and still full of bars, restaurants and entertainment, Philadelphia is a great place to look.
What about food and restaurants?
People hang their hat on New York’s unmatched variety of food. Philly has a great ecosystem of restaurants, bars and entertainment too. It may not match New York’s scale, but it has its own deep connection with the city. We are finally getting recognized on a national stage, with chefs who have won James Beard awards, and the Michelin Guide starting to rank and award restaurants here. I would put Philly up with pretty much any city in America for food.
I have visited a lot of cities and I always say I would love to live there, but I could not leave Philly because I would miss the food. You can get food from pretty much any culture or ethnicity here, and it is excellent. If you are scared of leaving New York because of the food, you will probably have fewer options, but there are excellent options in Philadelphia.
Checked November 20, 2026
The Michelin Guide announced its first Philadelphia selection on November 18, 2025, including three one-star restaurants. Source: MICHELIN Guide.
How does public transportation compare?
This is one of the biggest hits on living in Philly versus New York. New York’s public transportation is quite literally unmatched. Philadelphia has SEPTA, and we have had issues with it. There are plenty of bus routes and trolleys, but the subway is essentially two main lines, the Broad Street Line and the Market-Frankford Line. If you do not live close to those lines, using the subway gets inconvenient. We do have Regional Rail that can take you in and out of the city. I would not say there is no public transportation, but New York is much more robust and probably much more convenient.
Checked November 20, 2026
Since August 2026 SEPTA names its rapid transit lines by letter: the Broad Street Line is the B and the Market-Frankford Line is the L. Source: SEPTA L schedule and map and SEPTA B schedule and map. Our Moving to Philadelphia guide has fares and getting around.
Is Philadelphia walkable?
On the flip side, Philadelphia has a lot going for it on walkability. Biking and walking are pretty easy, and the neighborhoods are somewhat interconnected. It is also a much smaller city. Even from where I live, pretty far south in South Philadelphia, I can walk into Center City in probably 25 to 30 minutes if I want to.
Depending on where you work, it may be more affordable to own or rent close enough to walk to the office and skip public transportation. The walkability and the way the neighborhoods connect is one of the things I like most. New York is so big and sprawling that you are much more likely to rely on public transportation, whereas in Philly you might just walk or bike to where you are going and be completely fine.
What about jobs, and can I keep my New York job?
New York is one of the leading cities for corporations: finance, media, tech, fashion. There is a much larger job market there, and if you want global leadership roles in large corporations you will find them in New York. But since COVID a lot of those roles have become more accessible remotely. That is one of the drivers of the influx of New Yorkers. Even if you have to be in the office once or twice a week, you can live in Philly, work mostly remotely and pop into New York when you need to.
You can take the Acela and be in New York in an hour and a half to two hours. I know people who do that commute weekly and it works for them. They get the New York salary but pay the Philly cost of living, and they are willing to give up a little more time to live that lifestyle.
Philly is strong in healthcare, education and biotech, there are a lot of nonprofits, and we have Comcast. There is a growing community of startups and life sciences, with the Pennovation Works near Gray’s Ferry and expansion in the Bellwether District. But a lot of the people I see working in Philadelphia are in healthcare or at the universities. And do not sleep on remote work. A lot of companies are trying to bring people back, but many have committed to remote work staying, and that gives you a chance to cut your living costs while working for a larger company from afar.
When should you move to Philly, and when should you stay in New York?
Where Philly really wins is affordability, and a little more breathing room and space. I also think it is a little easier to get a sense of community here, because some neighborhoods are tight-knit and very walkable, so you are not going across the city and you have more chances to meet your neighbors. And if you work in a field where Philly has a strong job market, or you have a New York job that can be remote, that is an excellent opportunity to move to a new city, explore it and cut your living costs significantly.
You may want to stay in New York in three cases. First, if you crave the hustle and bustle and non-stop movement, since there is probably an unmatched level of access to restaurants and bars and entertainment there. Second, if your job requires you to be in New York very often. If it is once or twice a week it may be manageable, but more than that the commute might become an issue. Third, if you have a humongous budget and can pay a premium to live where you want in New York. Plenty of people stay in New York for their whole career and then move to Philadelphia when they want to cut costs and slow down. If you are crushing it and you love it, there is no reason to move.
If you are leaning toward Philadelphia, start with the Moving to Philadelphia guide, then look at the neighborhoods where New Yorkers tend to land. Graduate Hospital, Fairmount and Old City are close to Center City, and Fishtown and Northern Liberties have the L. When you are ready to talk, contact me.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to live in Philadelphia than New York City?
Yes, according to the people I have helped move. They say their money goes much further on housing, groceries and restaurants, and they can afford more space. Percentages I quoted in October 2025 were rough, so check current prices before you budget.
Can I live in Philadelphia and work in New York City?
Yes, if you only need to be in the office once or twice a week. I know people who ride the Acela in about an hour and a half to two hours and keep their New York salary while paying Philadelphia’s cost of living.
Does Philadelphia have a city wage tax?
Yes. The wage tax is 3.735% for residents and 3.425% for non-residents who work in the city as of July 2026. Factor it into your budget.
Is public transportation in Philadelphia as good as New York?
No. New York’s network is unmatched. Philadelphia has two main subway lines (the B and the L), plus buses, trolleys and Regional Rail, so living near one of those lines matters. The city is also very walkable.
Sources
Every figure on this page was checked against the source below on November 20, 2026. Where a source updates, we update the page and the date.
- City of Philadelphia Department of Revenue, Wage Tax. Checked November 20, 2026.
- MICHELIN Guide, MICHELIN Guide Reveals 2025 Northeast Cities Selection (November 19, 2025). Checked November 20, 2026.
- SEPTA, L (Market-Frankford Line) schedule and map, August 23, 2026. Checked November 20, 2026.
- SEPTA, B (Broad Street Line) schedule and map, August 23, 2026. Checked November 20, 2026.
- Bright MLS via Bright Stats Market Snapshot Report, All Home Types, October 2026 (retrieved November 20, 2026) (my own table, see the Market page). Checked November 20, 2026.
This post comes from my YouTube video Philadelphia vs New York City 2025 | Cost of Living, Lifestyle & Where You Should Move (watch on YouTube), published October 10, 2025.
Philadelphia County figures in this post are based on information from Bright MLS for the period October 1, 2026 through October 31, 2026. Information Deemed Reliable but Not Guaranteed.



